Saratoga Springs vs. Old Key West: Which Home Resort Is Right for You?

Saratoga Springs and Old Key West are sprawling, peaceful DVC resorts with convenient locations near Disney Springs. 

Both resorts have their advantages, but choosing between them comes down to more than your preferred accommodations. Contract expiration dates, resale prices, and how you plan to use your DVC points can all influence which Home Resort makes the most sense for you.

Let’s see how they compare.

More Spacious Rooms: Old Key West

As the oldest and original DVC Resort, Old Key West has some of the largest rooms among all the DVC Resorts. These spacious rooms are perfect for spending time with friends and family. The balconies in the One Bedroom Villas and larger units are extra large and more similar to patios with tables and chairs for al fresco dining. While the rooms underwent a full refurbishment in 2019, another round of “semi-hard goods” refurbishment is expected in 2026.

Old Key West One Bedroom Villa

While the rooms at Saratoga Springs are not as large as those at Old Key West, they recently had a full refurbishment.  In addition to a more modern look, its rooms have popular features such as Murphy beds (which have not yet been added to Old Key West) and more outlets for charging devices.  Saratoga Springs is also home to a unique room type that doesn’t exist at any other DVC Resort: the Treehouse Villas.  These standalone villas have three bedrooms, a full kitchen, living room, and large deck.

Saratoga Springs Treehouse Villa

More Elevators and Better Accessibility: Saratoga Springs

An important distinction between the buildings at Saratoga Springs and Old Key West is elevator access.  Having opened in 1991 before building codes were updated, Old Key West lacks elevators in most of its buildings.  The only ones that do have elevators are Buildings 62, 63, and 64, and none of these are the Near Hospitality House buildings.  If you have a wheelchair or ECV, you’ll need to request a ground-level room if you are not in one of these buildings at Old Key West.

If accessibility is a deciding factor for you, Saratoga Springs makes a better home resort since all of its buildings have elevators.

Which DVC Resort Has a Longer Contract?

Saratoga Springs has an expiration date of 2054, which is longer than most Old Key West contracts since they typically expire in 2042.  However, some Old Key West contracts were extended to 2057.  These extended contracts are harder to find and tend to go for a slightly higher price per point than a regular Old Key West contract.

Which Resort Has a Lower DVC Resale Price Per Point?

When someone is looking for a home resort with a low entry point, Saratoga Springs and Old Key West are common recommendations.  Currently, Saratoga Springs resale contracts go for an average of $108 per point. Old Key West resale contracts go for an average of $101 per point or $101 per point for an extended one though normally extended contracts go for a higher price per point.

Average price per point from September 2025 to September 2026

Looking at data from the past year, regular Old Key West contracts that end in 2042 are consistently cheaper than Saratoga Springs contracts and normally cheaper than extended Old Key West contracts.

While Old Key West may have a lower resale price per point, the purchase price is only one part of the overall cost of DVC ownership. Annual dues and the number of years remaining on the contract can also affect the long-term value of each resort.

More Dining Options: Saratoga Springs

Olivia’s Cafe at Old Key West is a favorite among some DVC Members.  However, if you tend to rely on quick service dining, your options at Old Key West are rather limited.  Good’s Food to Go (the main quick service location at Old Key West) is more of a kiosk than an actual restaurant, and it offers basic options like Mickey waffles, breakfast platters, hot dogs, cheeseburgers, and sandwiches.  

The Artist’s Palette

By contrast, the Artist’s Palette (the main quick service location at Saratoga Springs), has a wider range of more substantial dishes.  In addition to the basics, you can get entrees like grilled chicken and rice bowls, brisket sandwiches, herb roasted salmon, turkey meatloaf, and chimichurri shrimp.  Even the Paddock Grill pool bar has some heartier options like blackened shrimp tacos, a chicken-bacon waffle cone, buttermilk fried chicken sandwich, and chicken power bowl.   

Since both resorts are so close to Disney Springs, you also have some wonderful dining options nearby. 

Better Transportation Options: Saratoga Springs

The transportation options are nearly identical at the two resorts.  Bus transportation is available for all four theme parks and Disney Springs.  When taking the bus, it helps to give yourself extra time since the buses make stops at each of the resort sections before heading to the parks.  Alternatively, you can take a boat from either resort to the Marketplace side of Disney Springs.  

Saratoga Springs narrowly wins this category due to its walking path to Disney Springs.  When you stay at Saratoga Springs, you can take the path from the Congress Park section to Disney Springs.  The path is behind the Congress Park bus stop.

Ferry at Old Key West (Photo Credit: WDW News Today)

Saratoga Springs vs. Old Key West: Which Should You Buy?

Overall, you can’t go wrong with Saratoga or Old Key West if you’re looking for a great price per point, low points charts, a quieter DVC resort with plenty of room availability, and the convenience of being close to the dining and shopping of Disney Springs.  Which one would be the best home resort for you will depend on your priorities.

Category Old Key West Saratoga Springs
More Spacious Rooms ✓
More Elevators and Better Accessibility ✓
Longer Deed ✓ (if extended to 2057)
Cheaper Price Per Point ✓
More Dining Options ✓
Better Transportation Options ✓

If you want to guarantee that you’re in a building with elevator access, you prefer Murphy beds, you enjoy walking to Disney Springs, and you need more quick service dining options, Saratoga Springs may be the home resort for you.

If you prioritize larger rooms, a lower price per point (for a contract ending in 2042), or a longer deed if you’re able to find an extended contract, then Old Key West may be the right home resort for you.

Ultimately, the right Home Resort depends on how you vacation, your budget, and what you value most in DVC ownership.

Access all available Disney Vacation Club resale listings, or learn more about buying and selling with DVC Resale Market.

If you’d like to make an offer or request a free consultation about buying or adding to your DVC contract, the DVC Resale Market team is here to help!

Comments

Post a Reply